Results Blogged Live Via the East Coast Feed
Dolly night has come and gone and now we must send another contestant packing. Predictions on the net have either Ramiele or Kristy going home tonight and I agree. I do think it will be Ramiele over Kristy but only time will tell. Should Kristy make it through another week I think people will freak out and call Idol a conspiracy. Personally I don’t think that is anything new. Votes are rigged and always have been.
So who is it that will be going home? Of course anything could happen as it did last week with Jason in the bottom 3. Sit back and relax. This is American Idol
Feel free to leave your thoughts about the results show in a comment or chat live with us in the shoutbox on the sidebar. We always value your thoughts and opinions.
Slim Wants To Go : Ramielle Malubay
Slim Thinks Will Go : Ramielle Malubay Kristy Lee Cook
Angie Wants To Go : Ramiele Malubay
Angie Thinks Will Go : Ramiele Maubay or Syesha
Note : The results were blogged live via the East Coast Feed by angie. Everything is after the jump.
Official Idol Going Home: Ramiele Malubay
Hey, guys! Angie here, once again, to fill you in on the fun and games of elimination night. What do YOU think will happen?
The show gets started with a group song of “9 to 5″ and it was oh so very bad from the dancing to the singing. Nobody was on it 100%. Thank goodness for commercials!
On a side note, (because they are showing recaps and really, who wants to relive it? Well, except for that uber-sexy Michael Johns performance..but I digress.) I wish Ryan would wear something else besides a suit. I don’t think he wears them well. Also, I love Dolly Parton!
Sofa vs Stools time, kids!
The votes are in and Ryan calls Michael Johns out first and he is SAFE! (Love it!)
Archie toddles out in his nice boy sweater and he is SAFE! (duh)
Carly is next in one of those unflattering tops and Ryan messes with her head for a minute then tells her she is SAFE!
Back from commercials and we are again tortured with calls from fans. Syesha, David Cook, Randy, Michael and Simon are the lucky ones, tonight. It was slightly less painful than previous weeks, but not much.
The Clark Brothers (winners of The Next Great American Band) perform for more time filler. Thanks Nigel.
The Ford video/commercial was funny tonight with the Idols singing, “It’s Tricky.” It even featured stunt doubles! Idol rocks!
Sofa vs Stools time again!
David Cook is SAFE on the sofa!
Ramiele, in a fashion disaster, is the first to take a stool.
Kristy comes out with a note in her hand that says, “Kristy’s seat” as she is sure that she will get a stool. Aaaand she does. (She’s just a bit too cocky for me, tonight.)
Back from commercials, again, and we get a “Where are they now?” segment featuring Bucky, Bo Bice and Phil Stacey.
Sofa vs Stools v3.0
Syesha is safely on the sofa.
Jason and Brooke are the last two out to the stage.
Jason is SAFE!! (yesssssss!! And all is right with the world.)
Brooke is not. (NOOOOO! Ok, ALMOST all is right with the world.)
Official Bottom 3: Kristy, Ramiele and Brooke
Next up is the weekly “Idol Gives Back” segment. Then Dolly sings, “Jesus and Gravity.” Hmm, I really should have listened to that song because, well, Jesus and Gravity? What the H? But, I had to go to the shoutbox and defend my girl Brooke from the meanie-pants people.
The lights are dimmed. Ryan sends Brooke to safety!! (YAY!)
Kristy is safe and Ramiele is serenaded home by Ruben. Ryan comforts Ramiele and then she sings us out.
So, what’d you guys think? I am personally happy with the results. It was time for Ramiele to go. Leave YOUR thoughts in the comments and come join us in the shoutbox for discussion. Until next week…Angie, out.
[quote comment="28823"]I was trying to do a search for Ramielles height. Does anyone know how tall she is. I am just curious.[/quote]
4’11″
[quote comment="28822"]Kristi Lee Cook has got to be the luckiest. I think short of a miracle she will be gone next week.[/quote]
Cats have 9 lives. Kristy may have 10. It is inconceivable (to me ) that next week won’t bring her down BUT Slim says it is songs of the 21st century. Gretchen Wilson, Miranda Lambert, anyone? If that is the theme she has a lot more places to go then Michael or either David (not that I think they ae going anywhere), or Jason or Brooke. It is good for Syesha and Carly but who else except Kristy?
I was trying to do a search for Ramielles height. Does anyone know how tall she is. I am just curious.
Kristi Lee Cook has got to be the luckiest. I think short of a miracle she will be gone next week.
Is it just my perception or did it seem as if Syesha was offended that anyone might think that she was: 1 – imitating Whitney and 2 – not as good.
It was time for her to go. Kristi Lee Cook has to be the luckiest American Idol contestant ever. She has dodged a bullet every week.
[quote comment="28815"]America got it right. Ramiel did not deserve to be on that stage anymore. I cannot think of ONE song she performed excellently from beginning to end. Every week she was hit and miss, all in the same song. As to the idea that you can tell who is the ‘nicest’ by who stood by Ramiel tonight, that is a pretty lame conclusion based on nothing. Who knows why all the contestants did not come over to her. Perhaps they had been told not to. Perhaps they felt Ramiel had sufficient support tucked into the armpits of her two tall bookends. Perhaps the people who stood with Ramiel WERE HER ROOMMATES? Randomx6, a psychologist you are not![/quote]
Not to out myself but my degree says otherwise.
American definately got it right. The biggest mistake they made was not voting her off sooner.
America got it right. Ramiel did not deserve to be on that stage anymore. I cannot think of ONE song she performed excellently from beginning to end. Every week she was hit and miss, all in the same song. As to the idea that you can tell who is the ‘nicest’ by who stood by Ramiel tonight, that is a pretty lame conclusion based on nothing. Who knows why all the contestants did not come over to her. Perhaps they had been told not to. Perhaps they felt Ramiel had sufficient support tucked into the armpits of her two tall bookends. Perhaps the people who stood with Ramiel WERE HER ROOMMATES? Randomx6, a psychologist you are not!
[quote comment="28783"][quote comment="28778"]I know that certain people on this site think I am too opinionated (ahem – I read the shout box and notice my comments being vanished here) but I am going to follow up my earlier post by saying that, hands down, the 3 nicest people in this competition are clearly: Brooke; Carly; and David Cook. Their real honest reations to Ramielle’s pain said it all. Some other people, who I have heard others call nice, just were too wrapped up in their own worlds to
notice.[/quote]
Are you implying that others are just plain selfish because they didn’t go and comfort Ramiele? Maybe you are the one who’s wrapped up in your own world.[/quote]
Whatever you say – Don’t want to argue.
[quote comment=\"28792\"]does anyone know what next weeks theme is?[/quote]
Slim says it’s songs of the 21st century w/ Ms Carey as mentor. That could be real weird and wacky, don’t ya think?
Comments are eliminated when they are taken too far such as an argument that just won’t stop. When that argument starts to annoy the rest of the readers then it will be removed. When you open a post and see a quote me with 8 quotes from the same two people and that is all you see in the post it becomes annoying.
As far as I know, I have never seen you comment in the shout box.
Do not use this comment as a spring board to another argument as I will remove it.
I don’t understand the guff that Kristy Lee gets. She’s drop dead gorgeous and she doesn’t miss a note. I’d like to hear her tackle SOUL somewhat like when Reba covered Otis Redding’s “Respect,” and got rave reviews from Aretha herself. Kristy Lee keeps surviving. And next week may be a free pass for everybody like last year.
As we inch closer to the finals, I’m starting to understand how this is the best field ever. There have been individuals that may be better performers but not so many. Two more cuts and then it will start to hurt.
does anyone know what next weeks theme is?
Awesome blog btw Slim, keep up the good work.
[quote comment="28781"]I have to agree with Ramiele going home. I just don’t think she was mature enough for the show, and it was too big for her. I have to say I would have liked to see Jason in the bottom three though, his singing is so boring….and Kristy, she deserves to go for being such a negative sour puss….suck it up, sing better and people will vote for you!! This year I find the voters are actually voting according to the performances each night, so far…that’s a good thing. I’m from Canada and can’t vote so it is a bit frustrating…but my 3 favorites are still in the running….Carly, David C and Michael J…even though I truly believe David A will win it all…..[/quote]
Totally agree. those are the people that will make the top 5, David A (as much as other peoples trying to deny it) will go for the win.
[quote comment="28778"]I know that certain people on this site think I am too opinionated (ahem – I read the shout box and notice my comments being vanished here) but I am going to follow up my earlier post by saying that, hands down, the 3 nicest people in this competition are clearly: Brooke; Carly; and David Cook. Their real honest reations to Ramielle’s pain said it all. Some other people, who I have heard others call nice, just were too wrapped up in their own worlds to
notice.[/quote]
Are you implying that others are just plain selfish because they didn’t go and comfort Ramiele? Maybe you are the one who’s wrapped up in your own world.
I have to agree with Ramiele going home. I just don’t think she was mature enough for the show, and it was too big for her. I have to say I would have liked to see Jason in the bottom three though, his singing is so boring….and Kristy, she deserves to go for being such a negative sour puss….suck it up, sing better and people will vote for you!! This year I find the voters are actually voting according to the performances each night, so far…that’s a good thing. I’m from Canada and can’t vote so it is a bit frustrating…but my 3 favorites are still in the running….Carly, David C and Michael J…even though I truly believe David A will win it all…..
[quote comment="28778"]I know that certain people on this site think I am too opinionated (ahem – I read the shout box and notice my comments being vanished here) but I am going to follow up my earlier post by saying that, hands down, the 3 nicest people in this competition are clearly: Brooke; Carly; and David Cook. Their real honest reations to Ramielle’s pain said it all. Some other people, who I have heard others call nice, just were too wrapped up in their own worlds to
notice.[/quote]
I don’t know why your comments would have been deleted. I know I didn’t delete them.
I know that certain people on this site think I am too opinionated (ahem – I read the shout box and notice my comments being vanished here) but I am going to follow up my earlier post by saying that, hands down, the 3 nicest people in this competition are clearly: Brooke; Carly; and David Cook. Their real honest reations to Ramielle’s pain said it all. Some other people, who I have heard others call nice, just were too wrapped up in their own worlds to
notice.
I would have prefered Ramiele to be voted off next week just so Kristy wouldn’t get the big head for another week.. I’ll be looking forward to Kristy getting voted off NEXT WEEK! She’s really starting to annoy me with her attitude and she isn’t even all that.
I hope she gets the boot next time around!
Expected – deserved – still sad. It’s too bad she couldn’t bring her studio self to the stage. It took losing to bring her emotions up front and made the song MUCH better tonight. Still deserved, though.
Ramy: I knew she was gonna be gone because she was at the bottom of dial idol!
Kristi Lee Cook: Wow she is so negative! She wrote a little note saying Kristi’s chair. She has got to get rid of that negative.. Come on girl!!! positive is good!
It’s healther!
Dolly: WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! LOVE HER!!!
Wow even Simon gave him a standing O! The only time I have ever seen him do that is with Leona Lewis.
Idol gives back: The children are abused!?!?!?!!? :angry1: I’m so glad that that little girl found her sister!
Mikey Johns: I knew he was safe. I was smiling the whole time.. Oops I shouldn’t be cocky.
The questions: Yeah good question! Why DOES Simon have to apologize everytime he gives a negative critique?
awful hidous The Clark brothers :em75: :em75:
Cueing