Simon to me is the most accurate is his criticism but sometimes a little too hard. The sharp tongue is ok to a point. But he revels to much in being a put down artist. Paula is a sweetheart and often brings good advice to the table. Randy is not very articulate but has the right vibe most of the time. Kara has perhaps the best credentials of all in that she is a professional trainer and coach to the professional entertainer singers. Its yet to be seen how well she is able to use her skills to help the contestants but she has a lot to offer. And Kara is ohhhh soooo gorge-a-sexy-beautiful-delicious-looking toooo!!!!! # 1 :whistle:
Imho, Simon makes the show. :devil: I was sad to see that Randy came in last at the polls, however. :cwy: He’d be my 2nd pick with Paula next and Kara at dead last (not too fond of her yet).
I don’t know who I like best. I think they’re all pretty cool.
Simon- Hate when he is biased and mean for no reason, but at times he’s pretty funny and nice.
Randy- Probably the least interesting, but that’s not necessarily bad, is it? Someone out of the 4 has to be. But in a way he gives good feedback and he’s pretty cool for being the oldest judge of the lot.
Kara- New, and a lot more cool than I expected.
Paula- She’s alright, pretty boring this year so far. I used to actually kinda like her because she was nice. Once in a great while I want to slap her like a bitch (b/c of some of the things she says (ex: “I don’t think it’s gonna be good enough for the finals”) or things she doesn’t say (ex: “I—-I——I——————–” – during Kat McPhee’s ‘I Believe I Can Fly’ by the way [but probably only cuz Daughtry was off the week before lol]). And even though she can be really ‘out of it’ at times, I miss her quirkiness this year.
Simon is my fave but the show don’t work without all of them. Simon is a little too harsh at times thats why we need Paula and Randy. They can useualy find something good about the person or performance. The jury’s still out on Kara though. Ask again at the end of the season I haven’t seen enough of her to judge.
I like Simon because he is real and is honest with the contestants, Paula is mediocre, Randy isn’t sure what he is doing and has to agree with someone usually Simon, and the new judge Kara is terrible she brings too much jealousy to the table. I am not quite sure why they needed a 4th judge it ruined the show, what happens with the split decisions? It goes Simon’s way which it should, but still. Bottom line is get rid of that which isn’t needed, KARA.
[quote comment="48918"]Gotta go with Simon – he speaks the truth. Kara would be #2.[/quote]
This is what I was going to say. Someone took the words right out of my mouth.
Simon is my fave because he is the only one who makes comments that make actually be useful to the singer. Paula is #2 because she is so darn entertaining.
Simon to me is the most accurate is his criticism but sometimes a little too hard. The sharp tongue is ok to a point. But he revels to much in being a put down artist. Paula is a sweetheart and often brings good advice to the table. Randy is not very articulate but has the right vibe most of the time. Kara has perhaps the best credentials of all in that she is a professional trainer and coach to the professional entertainer singers. Its yet to be seen how well she is able to use her skills to help the contestants but she has a lot to offer. And Kara is ohhhh soooo gorge-a-sexy-beautiful-delicious-looking toooo!!!!! # 1 :whistle:
Simon for me also :wink:
Imho, Simon makes the show. :devil: I was sad to see that Randy came in last at the polls, however. :cwy: He’d be my 2nd pick with Paula next and Kara at dead last (not too fond of her yet).
kara stinks.
i love american idol :happy: :heart: :wub:
I don’t know who I like best. I think they’re all pretty cool.
Simon- Hate when he is biased and mean for no reason, but at times he’s pretty funny and nice.
Randy- Probably the least interesting, but that’s not necessarily bad, is it? Someone out of the 4 has to be. But in a way he gives good feedback and he’s pretty cool for being the oldest judge of the lot.
Kara- New, and a lot more cool than I expected.
Paula- She’s alright, pretty boring this year so far. I used to actually kinda like her because she was nice. Once in a great while I want to slap her like a bitch (b/c of some of the things she says (ex: “I don’t think it’s gonna be good enough for the finals”) or things she doesn’t say (ex: “I—-I——I——————–” – during Kat McPhee’s ‘I Believe I Can Fly’ by the way [but probably only cuz Daughtry was off the week before lol]). And even though she can be really ‘out of it’ at times, I miss her quirkiness this year.
Simon is my fave but the show don’t work without all of them. Simon is a little too harsh at times thats why we need Paula and Randy. They can useualy find something good about the person or performance. The jury’s still out on Kara though. Ask again at the end of the season I haven’t seen enough of her to judge.
I like Simon because he is real and is honest with the contestants, Paula is mediocre, Randy isn’t sure what he is doing and has to agree with someone usually Simon, and the new judge Kara is terrible she brings too much jealousy to the table. I am not quite sure why they needed a 4th judge it ruined the show, what happens with the split decisions? It goes Simon’s way which it should, but still. Bottom line is get rid of that which isn’t needed, KARA.
I like Simon and I like the clothes he wears even if some contestants don’t:.
Some people are very very ignorant !!
:angel: hey :wub: i would also say that randy is also the best he’s totaly cool!!!!! :wub: :tongue:
:wub: i gotta go with paula and kara b/c they are totaly the best at wht they do!!!!!!! :angel: :wub:
:whistle: He seems to be the only judge that makes up his own mind.
[quote comment="48918"]Gotta go with Simon – he speaks the truth. Kara would be #2.[/quote]
This is what I was going to say. Someone took the words right out of my mouth.
Simon. Simon. Simon. Simon.
Simon! :smile:
Gotta go with Simon – he speaks the truth. Kara would be #2.
Simon is my fave because he is the only one who makes comments that make actually be useful to the singer. Paula is #2 because she is so darn entertaining.