Group 1 Results Poll

Now that the results from Group 1 are in, did America get it right. Leave your vote in the poll below and any thoughts in a comment.

  1. joeyinc says:

    What was the deal with Ann Marie? She should have done better then that.

  2. metsfan57 says:

    Michael Sarver did not deserve this at all. He has no stage presence, and looked awkward with his weird dancing and facial expressions. Plus, his singing wasn’t great either. Randy and Kara nailed it when they said something just wasn’t right about his performance. However, America listened to Simon after he said he deserved another shot. The key phrase was ANOTHER SHOT. He didn’t perform well, and therefore, didn’t deserve to makr it through.
    Sure, Danny Gokey was the best so he deserved it.
    I didn’t like Alexis Grace’s performance at all, but that is because I didn’t like the genre of music at all. I would have wanted Tatiana through because of this. However, I’m not as mad over Alexis making it through as I am of Michael.
    Anoop deserved it way more than Michael. Anoop is a better singer and even has a better name.
    Anoop better be a wild card.

  3. randomx6 says:

    [quote comment="51066"][quote comment="51052"]Amy, there are currently 38 votes for “I’m not watching anymore”. Do those go in your tally? :whistle:[/quote]
    I was considering adding those, but then…. I don’t know. It’s not like somebody actually wrote it in a comment. What do you guys think?[/quote]
    Nope. Saying it affirmatively is different from forced poll choice…Oh by the way, if Michael or Danny wins I will not watch the show in 2011. :tongue:

  4. angie says:

    [quote comment="51066"][quote comment="51052"]Amy, there are currently 38 votes for “I’m not watching anymore”. Do those go in your tally? :whistle:[/quote]
    I was considering adding those, but then…. I don’t know. It’s not like somebody actually wrote it in a comment. What do you guys think?[/quote]

    My vote is no, too.

  5. Joyce says:

    [quote comment="51066"][quote comment="51052"]Amy, there are currently 38 votes for “I’m not watching anymore”. Do those go in your tally? :whistle:[/quote]
    I was considering adding those, but then…. I don’t know. It’s not like somebody actually wrote it in a comment. What do you guys think?[/quote]

    I say no

  6. ABB says:

    [quote comment="51052"]Amy, there are currently 38 votes for “I’m not watching anymore”. Do those go in your tally? :whistle:[/quote]
    I was considering adding those, but then…. I don’t know. It’s not like somebody actually wrote it in a comment. What do you guys think?

  7. Paula says:

    Everyone who made it last night are the ones i chose :biggrin:
    I’m so glad Micheal made it he is a guy you just have to like…The other two….Well you know.

  8. rachel says:

    [quote comment="51018"]
    I predict that Anoop will make it to wildcard via 4th place vote-getter, and Ricky will make it via Paula’s choice.[/quote]

    I could live with that !:smile:

  9. Joyce says:

    Amy, there are currently 38 votes for “I’m not watching anymore”. Do those go in your tally? :whistle:

  10. ABB says:

    [quote comment="50957"]
    I really not like the whole 3 people make it through the old way was so much better i mean the people only got one shot. how gay.[/quote]
    Not sure how gayness/homosexuality fits? Even the old definition of gay (happy) doesn’t fit. Wish kids would think about what they are saying.

    I predict that Anoop will make it to wildcard via 4th place vote-getter, and Ricky will make it via Paula’s choice.

  11. ABB says:

    [quote comment="51005"]Anoop better get a wild card spot or I’m going to fart in American Idol’s general direction.[/quote]
    :w00t: :w00t: :w00t: Thanks for the laugh!

  12. Braden says:

    Anoop better get a wild card spot or I’m going to fart in American Idol’s general direction.

  13. angie says:

    While I think Ricky is a really good singer, he was so forgettable, I am not surprised at all that he didn’t make it. He didn’t show much personality at all. I said in my blog yesterday that I would love to hear him do a lot more, but without personality, it’s hard to go very far on AI. (There have been a few exceptions to this over the years, but as a general rule it is true.)

  14. Lee says:

    The two guys with the hard luck stories and by far the most camera time got in. One deserved a top 12 spot definitely, but the other did not. It takes no imagination to figure out who. Ricky Braddy deserves to be there.[imo]
    But An AI influenced America has spoken. Maybe Ricky will get a wild card when the time comes, Unless AI sends him to obscurity-ville again and pedals who they want with their advertising. Got to say along with most every one else ” Two out of three ain’t that bad. :w00t:

  15. angie says:

    I preferred all three who made it. I would have been happy with Anoop in Michael’s place, too. Maybe even Ricky. I’m a happy camper, though. No, I don’t think Michael would ever win, but I prefer him over many of the others in this group.

  16. DJSlim says:

    [quote comment="50980"]I agree with random – a “2 out of 3 ain’t bad” option would have been nice. Michael just doesn’t do it for me.[/quote]

    i didn’t even think about it. sorry :angel:

  17. CB says:

    I agree with random – a “2 out of 3 ain’t bad” option would have been nice. Michael just doesn’t do it for me.

  18. randomx6 says:

    [quote comment="50957"]Well i really didnt like the results

    Michael- i dont think can thing and i so dont think his likeable.

    Danny- He is pretty cool and good singer.

    Alexis- I think compared to seasons past the girl isnt good and doesnt have what it takes.

    I really not like the whole 3 people make it through the old way was so much better i mean the people only got one shot. how gay.[/quote]
    Boy do I find your last line (to be polite) confusing.

  19. randomx6 says:

    I had to vote for not even close since there wasn’t an awwight but place. Michael should not be there.

  20. rachel says:

    I was sure about Danny and Alexis even before I read Dial Idol’s predictions. I thought either Ricky or Anoop would fill the third seat. Kind of surprised about Michael.
    I guess Dial Idol gets it right again !

  21. Cameron says:

    Well i really didnt like the results

    Michael- i dont think can thing and i so dont think his likeable.

    Danny- He is pretty cool and good singer.

    Alexis- I think compared to seasons past the girl isnt good and doesnt have what it takes.

    I really not like the whole 3 people make it through the old way was so much better i mean the people only got one shot. how gay.



Click Your Station From The Drop Down Above!

Unable To Use Our Regular Player ?

Click Here For More Options