Update : Poll Is Now Closed
Now that the results are in are you happy with who America sent home? Take a second and leave your vote and of course your thoughts in a comment.
Update : Poll Is Now Closed
Now that the results are in are you happy with who America sent home? Take a second and leave your vote and of course your thoughts in a comment.
[quote comment="27586"][quote comment="27571"][Not sure if you noticed last week, but when the girls all sang together on Wednesday night, Amanda was NOT singing.I think it’s because she simply can’t sing those songs without overpowering the others with her SCREECHING. [/quote]
I think it’s because she refuses to sing anything resembling a ballad. Remember, “Ballads are boring!” The girl sticks to her guns and more power to her for that, but this is not the time to be noted as being uncooperative. It just makes you look like you’d be hard to work with.[/quote]
Have any of you watched the CBS show “Rockstar?” There was a rocker chick named Dilana from South Africa by way of Houston. The band let her go because she was uncooperative and could only screech like a wounded elephant with strep throat. I detested her from day one. I noticed a lot of Dilana in Amanda as well. The crazy hair, the extreme makeup, the nasty gravel crusher voice, the attitude, the clothes. Maybe she needs to hook up with Dilana and screech backup. (insert smiley with ears plugged here)
[quote comment="27571"][Not sure if you noticed last week, but when the girls all sang together on Wednesday night, Amanda was NOT singing.I think it’s because she simply can’t sing those songs without overpowering the others with her SCREECHING. [/quote]
I think it’s because she refuses to sing anything resembling a ballad. Remember, “Ballads are boring!” The girl sticks to her guns and more power to her for that, but this is not the time to be noted as being uncooperative. It just makes you look like you’d be hard to work with.
[quote comment="27480"]Wrong again America (or Idol Producers… :em52:[/quote]
Sorry your favorite was voted off, you seemed to be in the minority. I am not so sure someone will pick her up as I don’t think she has that big of an audience to support a contract and record deal.
No one was wrong, especially America, most just didn’t care for her voice.
[quote comment="27569"][quote comment="27568"][quote comment="27564"]Amanda needed to go a long time ago[/quote]
At least our ears can take a break !!!! :em62:[/quote]
I agree…broken record is now gone[/quote]
Not sure if you noticed last week, but when the girls all sang together on Wednesday night, Amanda was NOT singing. I think it’s because she simply can’t sing those songs without overpowering the others with her SCREECHING. I hope she is not the one voted in to join the tour, since she will not be able to actually sing in group songs.
[quote comment="27568"][quote comment="27564"]Amanda needed to go a long time ago[/quote]
At least our ears can take a break !!!! :em62:[/quote]
I agree…broken record is now gone
[quote comment="27564"]Amanda needed to go a long time ago[/quote]
At least our ears can take a break !!!! :em62:
Amanda needed to go a long time ago
Yes, they got it right ! In my opinion, she should have gone home long ago.
I was SHOCKED that Carly was in the bottom three. I guess weekly performances DO matter. I always thought each singer had a fanbase that voted for their favorites no matter what.
I’m glad both Carly and Kristy will be in the top ten to go on tour. :em78:
America got it right. Someone has to go every week right? Kristy won’t be around much longer. It was just a matter of her or Amanda, next week it will probably be Kristy. Did anyone announce what the theme is for next week? Have a great day all.
i am super hopign for a better theme next week for the contestants to have better choices.
[quote comment="27480"]Wrong again America (or Idol Producers… :em52:[/quote]
You must be an Amanda fan. Sorry, pal. We all know that whoever the contestant is there are people out here who really like them. Watch for her on the indie charts, though. I think somebody will pick her up because she really has a niche market out there.
[quote comment="27477"]:em78: Hay-yule Yayess! :em78:
(Country music pronunciation of Hell yes.)[/quote]
I mispronounced “yes” it should be Yay-Yiss.
Wrong again America (or Idol Producers… :em52:
[quote comment="27474"]how is kristy still on this show????!?!?!?!?![/quote]
Because people are voting for her
:em78: Hay-yule Yayess! :em78:
(Country music pronunciation of Hell yes.)
how is kristy still on this show????!?!?!?!?!
current BFFs should stay to sing in the finals — mama brooke, baby ramielle and big bro david :)
america got it right.