Comments on: SYTYCD – Finale http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23 Wed, 23 May 2012 14:27:13 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.2 By: rachel http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23#comment-39329 rachel Fri, 08 Aug 2008 18:38:59 +0000 http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/?p=1900#comment-39329 [quote comment="39322"][quote comment="39311"][quote comment="39299"]Was anyone a little saddened by the fact that they rushed Twitch off stage and didn't give him a chance to say anything or thank anyone for his journey? He didn't get a video montage like both girls did either? I think they should have planned things a little better to give both him and Joshua a bit more time at the end.[/quote] Yes, I thought that a bit odd myself. And I think he did too. In fact, when everyone came out to congratulate Joshua, I didn't see Twitch there. I think they made more of Katee, the third place winner. After all, she got $50,000, the first time they gave the first place "girl" a prize. So Joshua won , I think, $100,000, the third place winner gets $50,000 and Twitch, the SECOND place winner gets NOTHING ? This seems rather odd to me. And unfair. So Katee won $50,000 because she is a "girl"? Why wasn't this mentioned during the beginning of the season ? I feel bad for Twitch. :sad:[/quote] I think the winner (Joshua) actually wins $250,000.00 I think, but I could be wrong. As for Twitch, I did see him out there as he was one of the ones who put Joshua on his shoulders. I still think he deserved a few moments though - given how amazing he was/is.[/quote] Thank you, Amanda. I wasn't sure what Joshua won.And I played back the video, and you were correct. There on the right WAS Twitch ! So thank you for pointing that out ! :smile: [quote comment="39322"][quote comment="39311"][quote comment="39299"]Was anyone a little saddened by the fact that they rushed Twitch off stage and didn’t give him a chance to say anything or thank anyone for his journey? He didn’t get a video montage like both girls did either? I think they should have planned things a little better to give both him and Joshua a bit more time at the end.[/quote]

Yes, I thought that a bit odd myself. And I think he did too. In fact, when everyone came out to congratulate Joshua, I didn’t see Twitch there.
I think they made more of Katee, the third place winner. After all, she got $50,000, the first time they gave the first place “girl” a prize. So Joshua won , I think, $100,000, the third place winner gets $50,000 and Twitch, the SECOND place winner gets NOTHING ? This seems rather odd to me. And unfair. So Katee won $50,000 because she is a “girl”? Why wasn’t this mentioned during the beginning of the season ? I feel bad for Twitch. :sad:[/quote]

I think the winner (Joshua) actually wins $250,000.00 I think, but I could be wrong. As for Twitch, I did see him out there as he was one of the ones who put Joshua on his shoulders. I still think he deserved a few moments though – given how amazing he was/is.[/quote]

Thank you, Amanda. I wasn’t sure what Joshua won.And I played back the video, and you were correct. There on the right WAS Twitch !
So thank you for pointing that out ! :smile:

]]> By: rachel http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23#comment-39328 rachel Fri, 08 Aug 2008 18:36:21 +0000 http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/?p=1900#comment-39328 [quote comment="39323"]I think is was good that katee also got a prize ...her and joshua were after all the Best couple! :biggrin:[/quote] But Twitch, coming in SECOND, not third, whether he was a guy or a girl, deserved SOMETHING as well. [quote comment="39323"]I think is was good that katee also got a prize …her and joshua were after all the Best couple! :biggrin:[/quote]

But Twitch, coming in SECOND, not third, whether he was a guy or a girl, deserved SOMETHING as well.

]]> By: Brenda http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23#comment-39323 Brenda Fri, 08 Aug 2008 15:46:47 +0000 http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/?p=1900#comment-39323 I think is was good that katee also got a prize ...her and joshua were after all the Best couple! :biggrin: I think is was good that katee also got a prize …her and joshua were after all the Best couple! :biggrin:

]]> By: Amanda http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23#comment-39322 Amanda Fri, 08 Aug 2008 15:35:12 +0000 http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/?p=1900#comment-39322 [quote comment="39311"][quote comment="39299"]Was anyone a little saddened by the fact that they rushed Twitch off stage and didn't give him a chance to say anything or thank anyone for his journey? He didn't get a video montage like both girls did either? I think they should have planned things a little better to give both him and Joshua a bit more time at the end.[/quote] Yes, I thought that a bit odd myself. And I think he did too. In fact, when everyone came out to congratulate Joshua, I didn't see Twitch there. I think they made more of Katee, the third place winner. After all, she got $50,000, the first time they gave the first place "girl" a prize. So Joshua won , I think, $100,000, the third place winner gets $50,000 and Twitch, the SECOND place winner gets NOTHING ? This seems rather odd to me. And unfair. So Katee won $50,000 because she is a "girl"? Why wasn't this mentioned during the beginning of the season ? I feel bad for Twitch. :sad:[/quote] I think the winner (Joshua) actually wins $250,000.00 I think, but I could be wrong. As for Twitch, I did see him out there as he was one of the ones who put Joshua on his shoulders. I still think he deserved a few moments though - given how amazing he was/is. [quote comment="39311"][quote comment="39299"]Was anyone a little saddened by the fact that they rushed Twitch off stage and didn’t give him a chance to say anything or thank anyone for his journey? He didn’t get a video montage like both girls did either? I think they should have planned things a little better to give both him and Joshua a bit more time at the end.[/quote]

Yes, I thought that a bit odd myself. And I think he did too. In fact, when everyone came out to congratulate Joshua, I didn’t see Twitch there.
I think they made more of Katee, the third place winner. After all, she got $50,000, the first time they gave the first place “girl” a prize. So Joshua won , I think, $100,000, the third place winner gets $50,000 and Twitch, the SECOND place winner gets NOTHING ? This seems rather odd to me. And unfair. So Katee won $50,000 because she is a “girl”? Why wasn’t this mentioned during the beginning of the season ? I feel bad for Twitch. :sad:[/quote]

I think the winner (Joshua) actually wins $250,000.00 I think, but I could be wrong. As for Twitch, I did see him out there as he was one of the ones who put Joshua on his shoulders. I still think he deserved a few moments though – given how amazing he was/is.

]]> By: rachel http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23#comment-39311 rachel Fri, 08 Aug 2008 13:08:31 +0000 http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/?p=1900#comment-39311 [quote comment="39299"]Was anyone a little saddened by the fact that they rushed Twitch off stage and didn't give him a chance to say anything or thank anyone for his journey? He didn't get a video montage like both girls did either? I think they should have planned things a little better to give both him and Joshua a bit more time at the end.[/quote] Yes, I thought that a bit odd myself. And I think he did too. In fact, when everyone came out to congratulate Joshua, I didn't see Twitch there. I think they made more of Katee, the third place winner. After all, she got $50,000, the first time they gave the first place "girl" a prize. So Joshua won , I think, $100,000, the third place winner gets $50,000 and Twitch, the SECOND place winner gets NOTHING ? This seems rather odd to me. And unfair. So Katee won $50,000 because she is a "girl"? Why wasn't this mentioned during the beginning of the season ? I feel bad for Twitch. :sad: [quote comment="39299"]Was anyone a little saddened by the fact that they rushed Twitch off stage and didn’t give him a chance to say anything or thank anyone for his journey? He didn’t get a video montage like both girls did either? I think they should have planned things a little better to give both him and Joshua a bit more time at the end.[/quote]

Yes, I thought that a bit odd myself. And I think he did too. In fact, when everyone came out to congratulate Joshua, I didn’t see Twitch there.
I think they made more of Katee, the third place winner. After all, she got $50,000, the first time they gave the first place “girl” a prize. So Joshua won , I think, $100,000, the third place winner gets $50,000 and Twitch, the SECOND place winner gets NOTHING ? This seems rather odd to me. And unfair. So Katee won $50,000 because she is a “girl”? Why wasn’t this mentioned during the beginning of the season ? I feel bad for Twitch. :sad:

]]> By: rachel http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23#comment-39310 rachel Fri, 08 Aug 2008 12:59:30 +0000 http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/?p=1900#comment-39310 [quote comment="39297"]Mary might not up to par with the contestants, but let's not forget you're comparing her to young, mostly college-aged students who are in their prime as far as their dancing and body condition. I didn't particularly enjoy the performance, but methinks she was probably a hell of a lot better in her heyday. I really loved the reunion bit, though. I like that they let us catch up with previous contestants, although I'm a little annoyed that Sabra wasn't there. She hasn't been on all season so I guess the rumours about her falling out with Fox must be true. She was never my favourite dancer, but I did like her and I'm a bit disappointed with the things I've heard about her since the show. Also, I am SO SO glad that Mia picked the pas de deux as her favourite dance. Katee and Will totally nailed it the second time around. (I was actually holding my breath during that turn!)[/quote] Mary is almost 40 years old, so I thought she did well for her age. Same with Nigel. [quote comment="39297"]Mary might not up to par with the contestants, but let’s not forget you’re comparing her to young, mostly college-aged students who are in their prime as far as their dancing and body condition. I didn’t particularly enjoy the performance, but methinks she was probably a hell of a lot better in her heyday.

I really loved the reunion bit, though. I like that they let us catch up with previous contestants, although I’m a little annoyed that Sabra wasn’t there. She hasn’t been on all season so I guess the rumours about her falling out with Fox must be true. She was never my favourite dancer, but I did like her and I’m a bit disappointed with the things I’ve heard about her since the show.

Also, I am SO SO glad that Mia picked the pas de deux as her favourite dance. Katee and Will totally nailed it the second time around. (I was actually holding my breath during that turn!)[/quote]

Mary is almost 40 years old, so I thought she did well for her age. Same with Nigel.

]]> By: rachel http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23#comment-39309 rachel Fri, 08 Aug 2008 12:58:02 +0000 http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/?p=1900#comment-39309 [quote comment="39295"]And yes, Kherington's smile was beautiful and infectious. The routine is still a favorite. Loved it again. :w00t: (Murphy w00t)[/quote] Agree. I thought Kherington was the most beautiful of all the girls. I especially enjoyed ALL of her and Twitch's dance routines that they performed together. Wow. [quote comment="39295"]And yes, Kherington’s smile was beautiful and infectious. The routine is still a favorite. Loved it again. :w00t: (Murphy w00t)[/quote]

Agree. I thought Kherington was the most beautiful of all the girls. I especially enjoyed ALL of her and Twitch’s dance routines that they performed together. Wow.

]]> By: CB http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23#comment-39301 CB Fri, 08 Aug 2008 10:59:31 +0000 http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/?p=1900#comment-39301 Awesome AWESOME show last night :smile: I was really happy with the judges' choices, especially "Bleeding Love", my personal fav & the lyrical one w/Twitchington. I had heard rumors around that there was a falling out between Sabra & SYTYCD and she was notable by her absence. Does anyone know what that was all about? Awesome AWESOME show last night :smile: I was really happy with the judges’ choices, especially “Bleeding Love”, my personal fav & the lyrical one w/Twitchington. I had heard rumors around that there was a falling out between Sabra & SYTYCD and she was notable by her absence. Does anyone know what that was all about?

]]> By: Amanda http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23#comment-39299 Amanda Fri, 08 Aug 2008 06:19:27 +0000 http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/?p=1900#comment-39299 Was anyone a little saddened by the fact that they rushed Twitch off stage and didn't give him a chance to say anything or thank anyone for his journey? He didn't get a video montage like both girls did either? I think they should have planned things a little better to give both him and Joshua a bit more time at the end. Was anyone a little saddened by the fact that they rushed Twitch off stage and didn’t give him a chance to say anything or thank anyone for his journey? He didn’t get a video montage like both girls did either? I think they should have planned things a little better to give both him and Joshua a bit more time at the end.

]]> By: Lauren http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/sytycd-episode-23#comment-39297 Lauren Fri, 08 Aug 2008 04:15:01 +0000 http://idolbloglive.com/idolblog/?p=1900#comment-39297 Mary might not up to par with the contestants, but let's not forget you're comparing her to young, mostly college-aged students who are in their prime as far as their dancing and body condition. I didn't particularly enjoy the performance, but methinks she was probably a hell of a lot better in her heyday. I really loved the reunion bit, though. I like that they let us catch up with previous contestants, although I'm a little annoyed that Sabra wasn't there. She hasn't been on all season so I guess the rumours about her falling out with Fox must be true. She was never my favourite dancer, but I did like her and I'm a bit disappointed with the things I've heard about her since the show. Also, I am SO SO glad that Mia picked the pas de deux as her favourite dance. Katee and Will totally nailed it the second time around. (I was actually holding my breath during that turn!) Mary might not up to par with the contestants, but let’s not forget you’re comparing her to young, mostly college-aged students who are in their prime as far as their dancing and body condition. I didn’t particularly enjoy the performance, but methinks she was probably a hell of a lot better in her heyday.

I really loved the reunion bit, though. I like that they let us catch up with previous contestants, although I’m a little annoyed that Sabra wasn’t there. She hasn’t been on all season so I guess the rumours about her falling out with Fox must be true. She was never my favourite dancer, but I did like her and I’m a bit disappointed with the things I’ve heard about her since the show.

Also, I am SO SO glad that Mia picked the pas de deux as her favourite dance. Katee and Will totally nailed it the second time around. (I was actually holding my breath during that turn!)

]]>